Claims

Please locate your Carrier below. If you don’t see your Carrier listed, please contact claims@thedunngroup.com 

Company NameWebsitePhoneInformation
A Central Insurance800-234-6926
Adirondack Insurance877-629-8003
Allegany Co-Op Insurance Group800-333-1679
Allied Group Insurance 800-282-1446
Allstate Insurance Company 800-255-7828
American Stategic Insurance866-274-5677
Amerisafe800-699-6240
Amtrust 888-239-3909
Applied Underwriters877-234-4420
Assurant800-852-2244
Berkley Aspire866-412-7742
Berkley Mid-Atlantic Group 877-262-4178
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate 800-661-6029Workers Compensation
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate 800-356-5750All Other Claims
Bitco Insurance Companies 800-253-1232
Brickstreet Mutual Insurance 866-452-7425
Bristol West Insurance Group 800-274-7865
C N A 877-262-2727
Chautauqua Patrons716-664-5813
Chubb 800-252-4670Personal
Chubb 800-699-9916Workers Compensation
Chubb 844-539-3801Business
Cincinnati Insurance Companies 877-242-2544
CM Regent Insurance Company
Conemaugh Valley Mutual 800-333-1679
Countryway888-223-3649
Donegal Mutual Insurance Company 800-877-9006
Dryden Mutual Insurance Company 800-556-5802Nights & Weekends Only
Eastern Alliance Insurance Company 800-336-3658
Erie & Niagara Ins Association 716-632-5433
Farmers of Marble Pennsylvania 800-545-7806
Foremost Insurance800-274-7865Auto
Foremost Insurance800-527-3907All Other Personal Claims
Hagerty Insurance800-385-0274
Harford Mutual Group 800-638-3669
Harleysville Insurance Company 800-421-3535Business
Harleysville Insurance Company 800-421-3535Personal
HDI Global Insurance Company 866-484-2053
Hudson Insurance Group866-546-3981All Other Claims
Hudson Insurance Group855-550-6825Crop Related Claims
ICW Group Holdings Inc. 877-849-4678All Other Claims
ICW Group Holdings Inc. 844-208-2513Flood & Property
ICW Group Holdings Inc. 877-442-9669Workers Compensation
J. C. Taylor Insurance800-272-6764jctclaims@jctaylor.com
Kemper 888-252-2799
Key Risk 866-847-8872
Laundry Owners Mutual 800-590-4404
Leatherstocking Cooperative800-886-8048
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company 844-325-2467Small Business
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company 800-362-0000Mid/Large Business
Lititz Mutual 855-725-5642
Livingston Mutual855-725-5642
LoVulloContact Us during normal business hours.
Main Street America Group877-425-2467
Markel Insurance Company 800-362-7535All Other Claims
Markel Insurance Company 800-500-3344Workers Compensation & Small Business
McNeil & Company800-822-3747
Memic Indemnity Company 800-636-4292Workers Compensation
Memic Indemnity Company 877-310-3343EPLI
Millers Mutual800-745-4555
Millville Mutual 800-465-4134Contact Us during normal business hours.
Motorists Insurance Group800-876-8766
Municipal Risk Management Workers' Compensation Pooled Trust 800-434-7760
National General800-468-3466
Nationwide Insurance800-421-3535Business
Nationwide Insurance800-421-3535Personal
New Jersey Casualty Insurance Company 800-367-6564Business
New Jersey Casualty Insurance Company 800-367-6564Property
New Jersey Casualty Insurance Company 800-367-6564Auto
New York Central Mutual800-234-6926
PA Lumberman's Mutual Insurance Company 800-752-1895
Penn National Mutual Casualty Ins. Co. 800-374-4990Workers Compensation
Penn National Mutual Casualty Ins. Co. 800-766-2245All Other Claims
Philadelphia Insurance Company 800-765-9749
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company 800-333-7642
Progressive Companies 800-776-4737
R T Specialty855-725-5642Contact Agent during normal business hours.
RLI Insurance Corporation 800-444-0406
Russell Bond800-333-7226
Safeco800-332-3226
Security Mutual Insurance Company
Selective 866-455-9969All Other Claims
Selective 866-455-9969Flood
ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company 800-365-4999New York
ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company 800-365-4999Pennsylvania
State Workers Insurance Fund 888-388-7943Pennsylvania
State Workers Insurance Fund 888-875-5790New York
Sterling Insurance Company 800-462-4661Nights & Weekends Only
The Hartford 800-327-3636Workers Compensation
The Hartford 800-327-3636Workers Compensation
Travelers Insurance 800-238-6225Business
Travelers Insurance 800-252-4633Personal
United States Liability Insurance Company 888-523-5545
US Assure800-987-3373
Utica First Insurance Company 800-456-4556
Utica National Insurance Group 800-216-1420
Wright National Flood800-490-9953
Zurich Insurance Company 800-987-3373